Numbered Sports Cards $250–$499

Shop Numbered Sports Cards $250–$499 at Joshua’s Cards Coins & Collectibles. Compare serial-numbered sports cards in the $250 to under $500 browsing range, with raw cards and professionally graded examples identified individually.

Explore Numbered Sports Cards $250–$499

Use the listing’s current price, card number, serial numbering, condition and actual photos to compare items within your collecting budget. Product prices and availability can change; the individual listing shows the current offer.

Related collections: Shop All Numbered Sports Cards · Numbered Raw Cards · Numbered Graded Cards.

WHERE HISTORY MEETS HOBBY

PHOTO AUTHENTICITY

Actual item shown unless stated otherwise.

What you see is what you receive.

Filter Products
Elly De La Topps Now 15/25 Elly De La Cruz RC 2024 Topps Now MLB Cincinnati Reds Baseball RC Card 68
Elly De La Topps Now 15/25 Elly De La Cruz RC 2024 Topps Now MLB Cincinnati Reds Baseball RC Card 68

15/25 Elly De La Cruz RC 2024 Topps Now MLB Cincinnati Reds Baseball RC Card #68

Regular price $277.73
Sale price $277.73 Regular price $277.73
Unit price
View Item & Photos
This 15/25 RC card is a rare and highly sought-after Elly De La Cruz rookie...
2022 Panini Score Brian Robinson Jr. autographed rookie NFL Commanders card graded SGC 10/10
2022 Panini Score Brian Robinson Jr. autographed rookie NFL Commanders card graded SGC 10/10

2022 Panini Score Brian Robinson JR. RC Auto NFL Commanders Card #338 SGC 10/10!

Regular price $388.85
Sale price $388.85 Regular price $388.85
Unit price
View Item & Photos
Up for sale is this 2022 Panini Score Brian Robinson JR. trading card listing: 2022...
Rare 23/25 Jackson Chourio RC 2024 MLB Topps Now Brewers rookie baseball card #104
Rare 23/25 Jackson Chourio RC 2024 MLB Topps Now Brewers rookie baseball card #104

23/25* Jackson Chourio RC* 2024 MLB TOPPS NOW - MLB Brewers Rookie Baseball #104

Regular price $277.75
Sale price $277.75 Regular price $277.75
Unit price
View Item & Photos
This 23/25 rare and limited edition Jackson Chourio RC baseball card from the 2024 Topps...
National Treas Brandin Panini 2014 Panini National Treas Brandin Cooks 29/49 Auto RGS-BC NFL Gear Materials
National Treas Brandin Panini 2014 Panini National Treas Brandin Cooks 29/49 Auto RGS-BC NFL Gear Materials

2014 Panini National Treas Brandin Cooks* 29/49 Auto #RGS-BC NFL Gear Materials*

Regular price $349.95
Sale price $349.95 Regular price $349.95
Unit price
View Item & Photos
New Slab! This 2014 Panini National Treasures trading card features NFL player Brandin Cooks with...
Josh Jung Topps NOW Josh Jung RC 20/99 2023 Topps NOW World Series Champs On Card Auto Texas IN HAND
Josh Jung Topps NOW Josh Jung RC 20/99 2023 Topps NOW World Series Champs On Card Auto Texas IN HAND

Josh Jung RC 20/99 2023 Topps NOW World Series Champs On Card Auto Texas IN HAND

Regular price $349.00
Sale price $349.00 Regular price $349.00
Unit price
View Item & Photos
IN HAND This Josh Jung Rookie Card is a must-have for any Texas Rangers fan...
Kirk Cousins Panini 13/49 Kirk Cousins RC GOLD AUTO 2012 Panini Momentum Rookie Football 170 PSA 7
Kirk Cousins Panini 13/49 Kirk Cousins RC GOLD AUTO 2012 Panini Momentum Rookie Football 170 PSA 7

13/49 Kirk Cousins RC* GOLD AUTO 2012 Panini Momentum Rookie Football #170 PSA 7

Regular price $315.57
Sale price $315.57 Regular price $315.57
Unit price
View Item & Photos
For all the football fans out there, we have a rare find for you! This...
2024 Leaf Gunner Stockton rookie autographed NCAA Georgia Bulldogs trading card graded 9.5
2024 Leaf Gunner Stockton rookie autographed NCAA Georgia Bulldogs trading card graded 9.5

11/59 Gunner Stockton RC* Auto Leaf Electrum Prospects NCAA UGA BullDogs SGC 9.5

Regular price $299.00
Sale price $299.00 Regular price $299.00
Unit price
View Item & Photos
The product is a 2024 Leaf Gunner Stockton rookie autographed trading card featuring the Georgia...
25 2022 Onyx Vintage Breece Hall /25 2022 Onyx Vintage Breece Hall On Card Red Ink Auto SP vAHA NFL Jets SGC 9.5
25 2022 Onyx Vintage Breece Hall /25 2022 Onyx Vintage Breece Hall On Card Red Ink Auto SP vAHA NFL Jets SGC 9.5

/25* 2022 Onyx Vintage Breece Hall On Card Red Ink Auto SP vAHA NFL Jets SGC 9.5

Regular price $299.00
Sale price $299.00 Regular price $299.00
Unit price
View Item & Photos
/25 SGC 9.5 Rookie Card! The product is a rare 2022 Onyx Vintage Breece Hall...
Ketel Marte Game TOPPS NOW 2023 MLB TOPPS NOW 9/49 Ketel Marte Game Base Relic Card 1055C D'Backs IN HAND
Ketel Marte Game TOPPS NOW 2023 MLB TOPPS NOW 9/49 Ketel Marte Game Base Relic Card 1055C D'Backs IN HAND

Ketel Marte 2023 Topps NOW #1055C WS Base Relic 09/49 MLB Diamondbacks

Regular price $361.07
Sale price $361.07 Regular price $361.07
Unit price
View Item & Photos
Ketel Marte 2023 Topps NOW #1055C blue game used base relic, serial numbered 09/49. This...
Alonso Topps NOW 5/25 Alonso 2025 NY Mets MLB Topps NOW Road 2 Opening Day 10 Card Set - PR 1088
Alonso Topps NOW 5/25 Alonso 2025 NY Mets MLB Topps NOW Road 2 Opening Day 10 Card Set - PR 1088

5/25* Alonso 2025 NY Mets MLB Topps NOW Road 2 Opening Day 10 Card Set - PR 1088

Regular price $325.00
Sale price $325.00 Regular price $325.00
Unit price
View Item & Photos
INCLUDES 5/25 Pete Alonso SSPOnly 1088 Sets Printed! Get ready for the 2025 MLB season...
Kyle McCord Bowman U 32/50 Kyle McCord GOLD RC Refractor 2023 Bowman U Chrome Card 101 State SGC 9.5
Kyle McCord Bowman U 32/50 Kyle McCord GOLD RC Refractor 2023 Bowman U Chrome Card 101 State SGC 9.5

32/50 Kyle McCord GOLD RC Refractor 2023 Bowman U Chrome Card #101 State SGC 9.5

Regular price $284.80
Sale price $284.80 Regular price $284.80
Unit price
View Item & Photos
This 32/50 GOLD Refractor is a rare 2023 Bowman Chrome trading card featuring Kyle McCord,...
Chris Sale 2024 Topps NOW #639 Orange Parallel 3/5 front
Chris Sale 2024 Topps NOW #639 Orange Parallel 3/5 front

3/5! Chris Sale MLB Braves 2024 Topps Now 12th In History 8 200k Seasons 639 CY?

Regular price $299.99
Sale price $299.99 Regular price $333.30
Unit price
View Item & Photos
ONLY 770 Printed! This 3/5! Chris Sale MLB trading card is a must-have for any...
DJ Lagway LEAF 5/7 DJ Lagway RC Auto 2024 LEAF FOOTBALL WH-DJL - Purple MOJO GATORS - SGC 9.5
DJ Lagway LEAF 5/7 DJ Lagway RC Auto 2024 LEAF FOOTBALL WH-DJL - Purple MOJO GATORS - SGC 9.5

5/7 DJ Lagway RC* Auto 2024 LEAF FOOTBALL WH-DJL - Purple MOJO GATORS - SGC 9.5

Regular price $283.30
Sale price $283.30 Regular price $283.30
Unit price
View Item & Photos
This 5/7 2024 Leaf DJ Lagway Rookie Card is a must-have for any National Football...
Bryce Young 2022 Peake Performance autographed football card graded SGC 10/6 with Alabama Crimson Tide image
Bryce Young 2022 Peake Performance autographed football card graded SGC 10/6 with Alabama Crimson Tide image

Bryce Young* 2022 Peake Performance 6/10 Auto Card #PKA-BY SGC 10/6 NFL Panthers

Regular price $374.96
Sale price $374.96 Regular price $374.96
Unit price
View Item & Photos
This is a fantastic opportunity to own a 2022 Bryce Young Peake Performance autographed card,...
Shota Imanaga TOPPS NOW 5/5 Shota Imanaga RC 1st Cub Rookie /15 Wins 2024 MLB TOPPS NOW Card 740 IN HAND
Shota Imanaga TOPPS NOW 5/5 Shota Imanaga RC 1st Cub Rookie /15 Wins 2024 MLB TOPPS NOW Card 740 IN HAND

5/5 Shota Imanaga RC 1st Cub Rookie /15 Wins 2024 MLB TOPPS NOW Card 740 IN HAND

Regular price $315.57
Sale price $315.57 Regular price $315.57
Unit price
View Item & Photos
This 5/5 limited edition 2024 Topps Now sports trading card features Shōta Imanaga, a rookie...
2021 Onyx Vintage College Shedeur Sanders Blue Ink Rookie Autograph Trading Card SGC 10/6
2021 Onyx Vintage College Shedeur Sanders Blue Ink Rookie Autograph Trading Card SGC 10/6

2021 Onyx Vintage College /400 Auto - Blue Ink Shedeur Sanders #CASS - SGC 10/6*

Regular price $363.77
Sale price $363.77 Regular price $363.77
Unit price
View Item & Photos
This 2021 Onyx Vintage - College Autographs - Blue Ink card features Shedeur Sanders, signed...
Press Pass Premium Leaf 28/49 2024 Leaf Press Pass Premium -Travis Hunter RC Auto Retro RA-TH1 - SGC 9
Press Pass Premium Leaf 28/49 2024 Leaf Press Pass Premium -Travis Hunter RC Auto Retro RA-TH1 - SGC 9

28/49 2024 Leaf Press Pass Premium -Travis Hunter RC Auto Retro #RA-TH1 - SGC 9

Regular price $350.00
Sale price $350.00 Regular price $350.00
Unit price
View Item & Photos
The product is a 2024 Leaf Press Pass Premium trading card featuring a rookie autograph...
DeVonta Smith Panini 2021 Panini Donruss DeVonta Smith RC 3/299 The Rookies Autograph TR-DVS SGC 10
DeVonta Smith Panini 2021 Panini Donruss DeVonta Smith RC 3/299 The Rookies Autograph TR-DVS SGC 10

2021 Panini Donruss DeVonta Smith* RC 3/299 The Rookies Autograph #TR-DVS SGC 10

Regular price $499.00
Sale price $499.00 Regular price $499.00
Unit price
View Item & Photos
This 2021 Panini Donruss trading card features DeVonta Smith, a Philadelphia Eagles player, with a...
Dylan Sampson Bowman U 6/10 Dylan Sampson RC Ties Vols TD Record 2024 Bowman U Now Football 30 READY
Dylan Sampson Bowman U 6/10 Dylan Sampson RC Ties Vols TD Record 2024 Bowman U Now Football 30 READY

6/10* Dylan Sampson RC Ties Vols TD Record 2024 Bowman U Now Football #30 READY!

Regular price $275.73
Sale price $275.73 Regular price $275.73
Unit price
View Item & Photos
Introducing the 6/10 Dylan Sampson RC Ties Vols TD Record 2024 Bowman U Now Football...
2024 Topps NOW Mookie Betts World Series game-winning sacrifice fly card, serial 4/5
2024 Topps NOW Mookie Betts World Series game-winning sacrifice fly card, serial 4/5

4/5* Mookie Betts 2024 Topps NOW LA Dodgers SAC FLY WORLD SERIES COMEBACK READY!

Regular price $474.95
Sale price $474.95 Regular price $474.95
Unit price
View Item & Photos
4/5 READY! SAC FLY SEALS WORLD SERIES COMEBACK! This limited edition Mookie Betts 2024 Topps...
2023 Leaf Metal Xavier Worthy autographed rookie card purple wave 2/6 SGC 9.5 NFL Chiefs
2023 Leaf Metal Xavier Worthy autographed rookie card purple wave 2/6 SGC 9.5 NFL Chiefs

2/6 2023 LEAF METAL XAVIER WORTHY RC Auto Purple Wave #BA-XW1 NFL Chiefs SGC 9.5

Regular price $388.85
Sale price $388.85 Regular price $388.85
Unit price
View Item & Photos
This 2023 Leaf Metal trading card features Xavier Worthy, signed by the player himself and...
29/49 2014 Panini National Treas Brandin 29/49 2014 Panini National Treas Brandin Cooks Auto RGS-BC NFL Materials SGC 9
29/49 2014 Panini National Treas Brandin 29/49 2014 Panini National Treas Brandin Cooks Auto RGS-BC NFL Materials SGC 9

29/49 2014 Panini National Treas Brandin Cooks Auto #RGS-BC NFL Materials SGC 9

Regular price $425.00
Sale price $425.00 Regular price $425.00
Unit price
View Item & Photos
Up for sale is this 29/49 2014 Panini National Treas Brandin trading card listing: 29/49...
Limited edition 4/25 NFL RECORD Brock Bowers 2024 Topps Now rookie football card Las Vegas Raiders TE
Limited edition 4/25 NFL RECORD Brock Bowers 2024 Topps Now rookie football card Las Vegas Raiders TE

4/25* NFL RECORD! Brock Bowers RC* 2024 Topps Now 87 LV Raiders TE Reception #15

Regular price $332.18
Sale price $332.18 Regular price $332.18
Unit price
View Item & Photos
4/25 NFL RECORD! MUST HAVE! For the football fanatics out there, this limited edition 2024...
Shota Imanaga TOPPS NOW 3/5 Shota Imanaga RC - 2024 MLB TOPPS NOW Card 647 COMBINED NO-NO Chicago Cubs
Shota Imanaga TOPPS NOW 3/5 Shota Imanaga RC - 2024 MLB TOPPS NOW Card 647 COMBINED NO-NO Chicago Cubs

3/5! Shota Imanaga RC* - 2024 MLB TOPPS NOW Card 647 COMBINED NO-NO Chicago Cubs

Regular price $333.30
Sale price $333.30 Regular price $333.30
Unit price
View Item & Photos
Limited Print Run! This 3/5! COMBINED NO NO! 2024 Topps Now sports trading card features...
BRETT/SANDBERG/BOGGS/RIPKEN 2022 Immaculate Quad Legends Material BRETT/SANDBERG/BOGGS/RIPKEN 2022 Immaculate Quad Legends
BRETT/SANDBERG/BOGGS/RIPKEN 2022 Immaculate Quad Legends Material BRETT/SANDBERG/BOGGS/RIPKEN 2022 Immaculate Quad Legends

BRETT/SANDBERG/BOGGS/RIPKEN 2022 Immaculate Quad Legends Material - 13/25 SGC 9

Regular price $269.97
Sale price $269.97 Regular price $269.97
Unit price
View Item & Photos
Own a one-of-a-kind piece of baseball history with this 2022 Panini Immaculate Quad Legends Materials...
SHOHEI OHTANI TOPPS NOW 31/49 SHOHEI OHTANI 2024 TOPPS NOW MLB Los Angeles DODGERS BLUE Parallel SGC 10

31/49 SHOHEI OHTANI* 2024 TOPPS NOW MLB Los Angeles DODGERS BLUE Parallel SGC 10

Regular price $261.94
Sale price $261.94 Regular price $261.94
Unit price
View Item & Photos
This is a rare 2024 Topps Now baseball trading card featuring Shohei Ohtani of the...
QUINN EWERS LEAF 3/5 2022 LEAF FLASH QUINN EWERS RC AUTOGRAPH Leopard Crystal BA-QE1 - SGC 8.5
QUINN EWERS LEAF 3/5 2022 LEAF FLASH QUINN EWERS RC AUTOGRAPH Leopard Crystal BA-QE1 - SGC 8.5

3/5* 2022 LEAF FLASH QUINN EWERS RC* AUTOGRAPH Leopard Crystal #BA-QE1 - SGC 8.5

Regular price $275.10
Sale price $275.10 Regular price $275.10
Unit price
View Item & Photos
The product is a 2022 Leaf Flash Quinn Ewers Rookie Autograph card, featuring a label...
Trevor Etienne Bowman U 12/50 Trevor Etienne RC GOLD Auto 2022 Bowman U Inception Chrome Refr. - SGC 9.5
Trevor Etienne Bowman U 12/50 Trevor Etienne RC GOLD Auto 2022 Bowman U Inception Chrome Refr. - SGC 9.5

12/50 Trevor Etienne RC GOLD Auto 2022 Bowman U Inception Chrome Refr. - SGC 9.5

Regular price $361.07
Sale price $361.07 Regular price $361.07
Unit price
View Item & Photos
This rare and highly sought-after Trevor Etienne RC sports trading card is a must-have addition...
2021 Panini Prestige Adam Thielen autographed football card blue parallel 62/99 Minnesota Vikings
2021 Panini Prestige Adam Thielen autographed football card blue parallel 62/99 Minnesota Vikings

2021 Panini Prestige Adam Thielen* Blue Xtra Points Auto 62/99 Minnesota Vikings

Regular price $275.00
Sale price $275.00 Regular price $275.00
Unit price
View Item & Photos
For avid fans of the National Football League (NFL), this 2021 Panini Prestige trading card...
Nico Collins Panini 23/25 Nico Collins RC Signed 2021 Panini National RMS-NC NFL Texans SGC 8.5/10
Nico Collins Panini 23/25 Nico Collins RC Signed 2021 Panini National RMS-NC NFL Texans SGC 8.5/10

23/25 Nico Collins RC* Signed 2021 Panini National RMS-NC NFL Texans SGC 8.5/10*

Regular price $399.00
Sale price $399.00 Regular price $399.00
Unit price
View Item & Photos
23/25 Rookie Auto! Signed National Treasure Materials Card! The product is a signed 2021 Panini...
Paul Skenes Topps NOW 2024 Topps NOW 26/49 Paul Skenes RC Blue Parallel Rookie Card 334 - MLB Pirates
Paul Skenes Topps NOW 2024 Topps NOW 26/49 Paul Skenes RC Blue Parallel Rookie Card 334 - MLB Pirates

2024 Topps NOW 26/49 Paul Skenes RC Blue Parallel Rookie Card #334 - MLB Pirates

Regular price $278.30
Sale price $278.30 Regular price $278.30
Unit price
View Item & Photos
For avid collectors of baseball trading cards, here's your chance to own a 2024 Topps...
Trevor Etienne Bowman U 3/10 Trevor Etienne 2024 Bowman U NOW UGA Dogs SEC Champs OT Win Card 54 READY
Trevor Etienne Bowman U 3/10 Trevor Etienne 2024 Bowman U NOW UGA Dogs SEC Champs OT Win Card 54 READY

3/10* Trevor Etienne 2024 Bowman U NOW UGA Dogs SEC Champs OT Win Card 54 READY!

Regular price $275.00
Sale price $275.00 Regular price $275.00
Unit price
View Item & Photos
3/10* READY! This limited edition Trevor Etienne 2024 Bowman sports trading card is a must-have...
BABE RUTH Griffey Jr 2022 Leaf In Game Used Grand Salami 6 #GS11 limited edition baseball card in SGC 7 condition with game-used memorabilia
BABE RUTH Griffey Jr 2022 Leaf In Game Used Grand Salami 6 #GS11 limited edition baseball card in SGC 7 condition with game-used memorabilia

BABE RUTH Griffey Jr Pujols 13/25 Leaf In Game Used GRAND SALAMI 6 #GS11 - SGC 7

Regular price $499.00
Sale price $499.00 Regular price $499.00
Unit price
View Item & Photos
This rare and collectible sports trading card features some of the greatest baseball players of...
Bryce Harper TOPPS NOW Bryce Harper 40/75 - Game-Used Base Relic - 2023 MLB TOPPS NOW - 992 - IN HAND
Bryce Harper TOPPS NOW Bryce Harper 40/75 - Game-Used Base Relic - 2023 MLB TOPPS NOW - 992 - IN HAND

2023 Topps NOW Bryce Harper Game Used Base Relic 40/75

Regular price $499.93
Sale price $499.93 Regular price $499.93
Unit price
View Item & Photos
This 2023 Topps NOW Bryce Harper game used base relic card is serial numbered 40/75....
Elly De La Bowman Elly De La Cruz RC 73/150 2024 Bowman Rising Infernos Mini Diamond Reds SGC 10
Elly De La Bowman Elly De La Cruz RC 73/150 2024 Bowman Rising Infernos Mini Diamond Reds SGC 10

Elly De La Cruz RC 73/150 2024 Bowman Rising Infernos Mini Diamond Reds SGC 10*

Regular price $361.01
Sale price $361.01 Regular price $361.01
Unit price
View Item & Photos
This is a rare and highly sought-after Elly De La Cruz RC SGC 10 sports...
2017 MLB Immaculate Collection dual relic card of Albert Pujols and Mike Trout numbered 88/99 graded SGC 9
2017 MLB Immaculate Collection dual relic card of Albert Pujols and Mike Trout numbered 88/99 graded SGC 9

2017 MLB Immaculate Collection 88/99 Albert Pujols/Mike Trout Dual Relics SGC 9*

Regular price $332.18
Sale price $332.18 Regular price $332.18
Unit price
View Item & Photos
This is a unique trading card from the 2017 MLB Immaculate Collection featuring two baseball...
2016 Bowman Platinum Presence Orlando Arcia auto green parallel card graded 9 Milwaukee Brewers
2016 Bowman Platinum Presence Orlando Arcia auto green parallel card graded 9 Milwaukee Brewers

2016 Bowman Platinum Presence Orlando Arcia* 40/75 Auto* - Brewers/Braves #PP-15

Regular price $298.97
Sale price $298.97 Regular price $298.97
Unit price
View Item & Photos
New Slab! This 2016 Bowman Platinum Presence Green trading card features Orlando Arcia, signed with...
Juan Soto Topps Now 97/99 Juan Soto Autograph 2021 Topps Now Road to Opening Day MLB Card OD-286A
Juan Soto Topps Now 97/99 Juan Soto Autograph 2021 Topps Now Road to Opening Day MLB Card OD-286A

97/99* Juan Soto Autograph* 2021 Topps Now Road to Opening Day MLB Card #OD-286A

Regular price $337.74
Sale price $337.74 Regular price $337.74
Unit price
View Item & Photos
The product is a rare and valuable 2021 Topps Now Road to Opening Day MLB...
SHOTA IMANAGA Topps Now 8/10 SHOTA IMANAGA RC - 2024 Topps Now MLB Chicago Cubs Rookie 105 Opening Day
SHOTA IMANAGA Topps Now 8/10 SHOTA IMANAGA RC - 2024 Topps Now MLB Chicago Cubs Rookie 105 Opening Day

8/10* SHOTA IMANAGA RC - 2024 Topps Now MLB Chicago Cubs Rookie #105 Opening Day

Regular price $343.02
Sale price $343.02 Regular price $343.02
Unit price
View Item & Photos
This 23/25 limited edition 2024 Topps Now sports trading card features Shota Imanaga, a rookie...
Travis Hunter 2024 Mania American PRC Heisman Winner rookie card graded SGC 10, limited 3/5 collectible football card
Travis Hunter 2024 Mania American PRC Heisman Winner rookie card graded SGC 10, limited 3/5 collectible football card

3/5 Travis Hunter 2024 Mania American PRC Heisman Winner 2025 NFL Draft - SGC 10

Regular price $425.00
Sale price $425.00 Regular price $425.00
Unit price
View Item & Photos
3/5 SGC 10 Rookie Card! The product is a rare and collectible Travis Hunter 2024...
Sort by
  • Featured
  • Most relevant
  • Best selling
  • Alphabetically, A-Z
  • Alphabetically, Z-A
  • Price, low to high
  • Price, high to low
  • Date, old to new
  • Date, new to old

Recently Viewed